Watched: 06/08/2024
Format: BluRay
Viewing: I've lost track. 5th?
Director: Andrew Stanton
Selection: Joint household
You can see prior posts on John Carter books and movies here.
Back in 2012 when this movie came out, I'd read the novel A Princess of Mars at least twice. It's a breezy, fun read, the first of Edgar Rice Burroughs' John Carter of Mars/ Barsoom novels. If you can get past some very not-21st Century politics and concepts, they're an interesting read, and I recommend.
Those books were almost 100 years old when the movie was released, so, suffice to say, folks have enjoyed them for a while. And there's something to be said for any novels that last a century, and double that appreciation when it comes to any genre material that manages to last beyond a few decades. There's something there. So it came as a bit of a surprise to me at the time that this movie got the critical lambasting it received, currently residing at a 51 on Metacritic. And most of the folks who saw it at the time told me "oh, I hated that."
Look, your faithful blogger has just enough ego to assume it's everyone else who is wrong sometimes, but this was a case where I said "ah, well, it's working for me. I dunno." and moved on with my life.
But, to be truthful, it's been quite some time since I re-watched this movie or read that first novel, and with some separation, I now more or less get why this movie got the reaction it did. And TheWrap put out a fascinating history of the film, that I consider good reading.
To be blunt, I was familiar enough with the book that the movie was just seeing portions of the book come to life, and knowing there were many more books, I thought they were just moving things forward in order to make a more seamless narrative.
Nope.
There's essentially two large problems with the movie in my mind at this point -