Watched: 01/102/2024
Format: Disney+
Viewing: First
Director: James Mangold
Selection: Jamie
I was aware that the critical consensus and box office on Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny (2023) was not good. Neither of those things are much a deterrent for me for watching or enjoying a movie (see the many Godzilla posts on this site), but it did catch me by surprise when it happened. After the fan-lambasting and luke-warm critical reception of the last time Ford revisited the character in Indiana Jones and the Crystal Skull, I figured if Disney was going to go back to the well and offer another movie (after that one at least had the decency to give us a particularly happy ending for Indy), they'd be working to make sure that this one was well worth the return for cast and fans alike.
At the top, this wasn't what I would have hoped for in a big-screen return of Indy. If you liked it, and many people did, just a heads up. But, as always, I am not here to tell you what to like or not to like, just how I took in the movie.
The thing I was not expecting out of an Indiana Jones film was to feel bored. And at well over two hours... that's a lot of looking at my watch.
There was a big opportunity here for Disney, owners of the Lucasfilm output, as Crystal Skull was widely disliked and a new finale to the series could revive the franchise somehow, maybe get some life/ money out of the franchise yet. But, the window is closing on the value of that license with Ford now a guy in his 80's and the horrific realization that - just like Star Wars - there was going to be a response somewhere between "meh" and "you ruined my childhood" with a recast of the role.
All they could really do was hope to test the waters on a new action hero to carry the torch, and the obvious choice was (checks notes) Fleabag's Phoebe Waller-Bridge. And maybe they could keep Ford around for another picture or two to cement the hand-off.
I don't know if that was the plan, but, man, the movie really leaned into wanting you to find Waller-Bridge's character an equal (or better!) to Indiana Jones. The ten year plan can't be "count on a guy in his 80's to still jump around in 2032".
But that's speculation. Looking at Dial of Destiny, the movie didn't work for me in a few fundamental ways: