Watched: 12/16/2022
Format: Amazon Watch Party
Viewing: First
Decade: 2000's
Director: Ron Howard
People love this movie. I was aware of that, but had no interest in the film when it came out. I'd read the book a lot as a kid, and I'm a purist when it comes to Chuck Jones and my enjoyment of his work. And aside from some of the finest Looney Tunes installments, the annual TV special of How the Grinch Stole Christmas was his signature work. As a collaborative work (Jones, Seuss, Karloff, Ravenscroft, Poddany) it's hard to top.
Director Ron Howard never saw a project he couldn't make more mediocre by running it through his Hollywoodtron-3000. He understands the beats of movies, and deploys bombastic music and whatnot to get the audience on board as he takes them through their paces, but the movies always wind up feeling hollow and less than the sum of their parts. Yes, I know he was funny on Arrested Development. But I don't know how you take The Grinch and make a faux Tim Burton film that also manages to reframe the original story to such a degree that you miss the point of a children's book.
Look, part of the joke of the original Grinch book is that he's just a bastard. No one made him that way. We can speculate about shoe sizes and head fittings, but as far as we're concerned, he's just the local jerk who watches from afar. He simply is. But the original book is 64 pages, with a few sentences per page and lots of art. The movie needs a decent runtime, and so the filmmakers (and Howard is a director, but he's also basically a producer) padded and padded and padded some more! They padded this out til their padders were sore!
I mean, they had to pad the book for a 20-something minute cartoon version of the book.
So - we get a backstory for the Grinch where we see maybe it's nature that the Grinch is an asshole, but also it turns out those harmless Who's in Whoville are frightened, judgy assholes who elect the worst of them to run things.