Watched: 11/04/2025
Format: Criterion Channel
Viewing: First
Director: Harold Clurman
I know a tiny smidge about the Group Theatre in New York in the pre-WWII era, and have made a few connections over the years. And so it was that I saw Clifford Odets' name come up during the opening credits as the screenwriter, and I got a rough idea of the film that was about to unspool. Odets was an actor who participated in the Group Theatre movement before finding his footing as a writer - in fact, the writer upon whom the Coen Bros. based the titular character in Barton Fink.
So while Criterion included this movie in with "Blackout Noir", as in "people who lost time and are trying to recover what happened", my attention shifted to the usual social issues and naturalism that I expected to populate the film. Curiously, the film is also directed by Harold Clurman, one of the Group Theatre directors - in his sole film directing credit. Methinks it did not go well.
The major spoiler I'll drop here at the beginning is that this movie seems like a wandering mess until the finale slam dunks everything you've seen before, tying together themes, plot elements and character motivation that has seemed... wandering at best. Honestly, tip of the hat to that end, which is how I'll remember the film.























