Watched: 07/11/2026
Format: Library DVD
Viewing: 2nd or 3rd
Director: Frank Capra
Back in high school, this 6'4" jock/nerd quit playing on the school's JV basketball team, feeling his career in organized sports was, in fact, kind of un-fun and pointless. And without getting into a long story, I quit the team mid-season to go audition for a play. I wound up as an understudy, and the next fall, was in two plays.
The second play was You Can't Take It With You, by Moss Hart and George S. Kaufman. I am sure the performances were mediocre and our staging bad. But it did mean I was very familiar with the play at one point in my life. I've also seen video-recorded versions since, one starring Jason Robards. It is, in fact, a really good show when I am not in it.
The play must have been a huge hit when it was staged in 1936 as it was almost immediately turned into a film. In 1938, You Can't Take It With You would go on to become an Oscar-winning film, directed by Frank Capra (you know, the guy behind It's a Wonderful Life). It received 7 nominations and won 2, for Best Picture and Best Director.
The film is not exactly a direct translation of the play. As it's a movie, they have different locales and scenes, and different roles are emphasized and others reduced. The couple at the center of the play are really a plot point to force two very different families to spend time together - one a conservative, New York old-money family, and one a wacky set of eccentrics chasing their bliss. In the film, the young romantic couple are elevated to the main characters - played by a very young Jimmy Stewart and Jean Arthur.
It's a comedy of clashing ideals - summed up with the belief of the Sycamore family that there's no reason to spend a life toiling for money and fame if you can't take it with you, natch.
Lionel Barrymore plays "Grandpa", the heart of the show. Ann Miller was, like, 14 when she lied about her age and was signed to RKO who lent her to Columbia where she, now 15, played a 20-something married woman who spends the movie mostly on-point. Yes, she seems older than her real age. "That Guy"actor Dub Taylor plays her goofy husband who plays the xylophone and likes to use a printing press. The whole cast is solid, but those are the players I'm most familiar.
I think what I'd say is that the movie definitely feels like it's had Frank Capra's hands all over it. While the themes don't fundamentally change, the stakes are much higher, the notion of the needs of the many trumping the needs of the few is woven throughout, and as the Depression is wearing on, social commentary is added in. The Kirby's are bankers, and much is made about the mindset of the wealthy, and while history doesn't repeat itself, a lot of what we're hearing again these days sure rhymes with the words out of Kirby's mouth.
And it's kind of remarkable how few movies can or are willing to be just go ahead and say the quiet part out loud about the wealthy and the imbalance and the impact on everyone else. This isn't really a concern at all in the play, by the way - it's more a comedy of manners.
Anyway - I enjoyed the movie a great deal. It could stand a remake today.
For the record - I played the small part of the Dad, "Paul Sycamore", in the play, didn't have many lines, and was supposed to set off fireworks live on stage, but the lighting guys were assholes and missed their cue and I couldn't see the wick in the dark. We had words after that show.









