Watched: 04/26/2026
Format: HBOmax
Viewing: Unknown
Director: Bryan Singer
I was maybe ten minutes into this rewatch of Superman Returns (2006) when I messaged Stuart that we needed to bring back the podcast just to do a ten-part series on this movie. The pre-history of the movie is worth discussing, as is the production, months up to the release, the lackluster response to the movie, what came after with a reboot in the form of the Snyder movies, and that both the director and Spacey were canceled.
It's also a movie from the wild west, excited days of the superhero explosion that came after two great Spider-Man and X-Men movies, Batman Begins and a terrible Catwoman film.* But no real rules had been written yet for how superhero films should work.
The DVD releases of the Superman quadrilogy had really brought the Donner film and its sequels back to the public consciousness, and looking for a safe bet, with Batman done and Wonder Woman the only other DC IP that seemed possible - but that was a girl and Catwoman had failed - they went back to DC's original moneymaker.
Here, I'm just really going to cover the movie - but really what I thought at the time versus where I am in 2026.








